Chiari Malformation in Adults: Symptoms, Scans and When Surgery Is Considered
Updated: 1 day ago

Many adults learn they have a Chiari malformation only because an MRI scan was done for something else, and many of them never need treatment [1]. Surgery is considered when symptoms are severe or the spinal cord is affected, not because of the scan finding alone [1]. I am a neurosurgeon working in my own clinic in Izmir, Turkey, and in this article I explain what the diagnosis means, which symptoms matter and how decisions about surgery are made.
In brief
Many adults learn they have a Chiari malformation only from an MRI scan done for something else, and many never need treatment [1].
In one large US series, 14% of people with a Chiari I malformation on MRI had no symptoms from it [2].
Surgery is considered for severe headaches or problems caused by pressure on the spinal cord, not for the scan finding alone [1].
New problems using your hands, difficulty walking, or bladder or bowel changes can be signs of syringomyelia and need prompt review [1].
What is a Chiari malformation?
A Chiari malformation is where the lower part of the brain, the cerebellar tonsils, pushes down into the spinal canal [1]. There are four main types; type 1 (Chiari I) is the most common and is the type usually found in adults [1]. It tends to be present from birth, but it is normally only found in adulthood, when symptoms develop or when an MRI scan is done [1]. In many people part of the skull is thought to be too small for the brain [1].
Is Chiari common on MRI scans?
It is not rare. In one large US series of 22,591 people who had MRI scans of the head and neck, 175 had a Chiari I malformation with the tonsils lying more than 5 mm below the base of the skull, and 25 of those (14%) had no symptoms from it [2]. The authors concluded that the scan finding on its own says little about what will happen in future [2]. This study comes from a single centre, but its message is useful: a report that says "Chiari" is the start of an assessment, not a decision to operate.
What symptoms can Chiari cause?
The NHS lists these symptoms [1]:
headache, usually at the back of the head, which may be brought on or made worse by coughing, straining, sneezing or bending over
neck pain
dizziness and balance problems
muscle weakness, numbness or tingling
problems with vision or swallowing
hearing loss and tinnitus
nausea, insomnia and depression
The headache pattern matters. A headache at the back of the head that comes on with coughing or straining fits Chiari better than a general, everyday headache. When a patient brings me their scan, my first question is whether their symptoms match the anatomy on the images.
What is syringomyelia, and why does it matter?
In some people with Chiari, a fluid-filled cavity called a syrinx develops inside the spinal cord. This is called syringomyelia, and it can damage the spinal cord if it is not treated promptly [1]. It can cause problems using the hands, difficulty walking, pain and problems with bladder or bowel control [1]. A syrinx is one of the findings that changes the conversation about treatment.
Do I need treatment?
You might not need any treatment if you have no symptoms [1]. Painkillers can help with headaches and neck pain [1]. Surgery may be recommended if your headaches are severe or you have problems caused by pressure on your spinal cord, such as difficulty with movement [1].
What does Chiari surgery involve?
The main operation is decompression surgery. Under general anaesthetic, a cut is made at the back of the head and the surgeon removes a small piece of bone from the base of the skull, sometimes also from the top of the spine, to reduce pressure and let the fluid around the brain and spinal cord flow normally [1].
Surgeons differ on whether to open the outer covering of the brain (the dura) and patch it, a step called duraplasty. Two systematic reviews of adult studies help here:
In 12 observational studies, bony decompression alone was followed by more repeat operations than decompression with duraplasty, but clinical improvement was not higher with duraplasty [3].
In 24 studies including 1,006 adults, leaving the thin arachnoid layer intact during duraplasty was linked with fewer complications related to spinal fluid and fewer repeat operations [4].
Both reviews rely mainly on observational studies, so they guide choices rather than settle them.
What can I expect after surgery?
The aim of surgery is to stop existing symptoms getting worse; some people also notice improvement, particularly in their headaches [1]. Surgery sometimes brings no improvement, or symptoms get worse, and there is a small risk of serious complications such as paralysis or stroke [1]. I discuss these risks openly before any decision. Time in hospital and recovery depend on the operation and on you; your surgical team will give you an individual plan.
Where do I start in the UK?
If Chiari has been found on your scan, your GP and NHS neurology or neurosurgery services are the right first step. If you have already been diagnosed, the NHS advises contacting your doctor if you develop new symptoms or your symptoms get worse [1].
Some people also want a neurosurgeon to look at their scan and explain what it shows. You can read how this works in can I use my NHS MRI for a second opinion.
When to see a doctor
Call 999: sudden weakness or numbness on one side of the body, a drooping face or slurred speech — these can be signs of a stroke [5].
Contact your doctor promptly: if you have Chiari and develop new symptoms or your symptoms get worse [1], especially new problems using your hands, difficulty walking, or changes in bladder or bowel control, which can be signs of syringomyelia [1].
See your GP: headaches at the back of the head brought on by coughing or straining, or ongoing neck pain, dizziness or tingling [1].
Frequently asked questions
Can a Chiari malformation be found by chance?
Yes. It is often found only after an MRI scan done for another reason, and many people have no symptoms [1].
Does every Chiari malformation need surgery?
No. You may not need treatment if you have no symptoms [1]. Surgery is considered for severe headaches or problems caused by pressure on the spinal cord [1].
What is the operation for Chiari?
Decompression surgery: a small piece of bone is removed from the base of the skull, and sometimes from the top of the spine, to relieve pressure [1].
Will surgery cure my symptoms?
Surgery aims to stop symptoms getting worse, and some people improve, especially their headaches; it does not help everyone [1].
Send me your MRI for a review
If you would like a neurosurgeon to look at your scan and explain what it shows, send me your MRI scans and report on WhatsApp and I will review them personally. A review of images is not a full assessment, which also needs your history and an examination. See information for UK patients.
Written by Kaan Tugberk Ozdemir, MD — Neurosurgeon | Izmir, Türkiye · Last updated: November 2026. This article is for general information and does not replace a consultation.
Sources
NHS. Chiari malformation. Page last reviewed: 9 November 2022. Accessed: 12 November 2026.
Meadows J, et al. Asymptomatic Chiari Type I malformations identified on magnetic resonance imaging. J Neurosurg. 2000;92(6):920-6.
Förander P, et al. The case for duraplasty in adults undergoing posterior fossa decompression for Chiari I malformation: a systematic review and meta-analysis of observational studies. Clin Neurol Neurosurg. 2014;125:58-64.
Osborne-Grinter M, et al. Posterior Fossa Decompression and Duraplasty with and without Arachnoid Preservation for the Treatment of Adult Chiari Malformation Type 1: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. World Neurosurg. 2021;151:e579-e598.
NHS. Stroke — Symptoms. Page last reviewed: 12 September 2024. Accessed: 13 November 2026.




Comments